Is Mawlid Haram? Evidence, Scholarly Opinions, and Debate

The question “Is Mawlid Haram?” is one of the most common questions asked by Muslims today. Mawlid, which is the celebration of the Prophet Muhammad ﷺ’s birthday, has been a topic of discussion for a long time. Some Muslims celebrate it by coming together for religious gatherings, reading the Qur’an, helping the poor, and giving talks about the Prophet’s life. However, others disagree and consider it an innovation (bid‘ah) not rooted in Islam.

The matter is simple.yet It needs a careful look at the views of scholars, the rules of Islamic law, and the difference between cultural traditions and religious teachings. This article will explore both sides of the debate in detail.

Why some scholars consider Mawlid haram

Some people say that celebrating Mawlid is not allowed because they believe it is an innovation in religion, called bid’ah. They claim that the Prophet ﷺ, his companions, and the early followers of Islam never celebrated Mawlid, so they think it is something that shouldn’t be added to the religion. Key reasons given include:

Absence in early Islam: neither the Prophet ﷺ nor his followers held celebrations for his birthday. For those scholars, adding this tradition later is not allowed because it’s seen as an impermissible innovation.

Fear of excess: They worry that the gatherings for Mawlid might cause people to praise the Prophet ﷺ too much, almost like worshiping him, which Islam strictly forbids.

Mixing with prohibited acts: In some cultures, Mawlid is celebrated with music, dancing, or practices that contradict Islamic principles. These scholars argue that such practices cannot be justified under the name of religion.

From their perspective, answering “Is Mawlid Haram?” results in a clear “yes” because they see it as an unwarranted addition to Islamic practice.

Curate your Islamic learning journey: schedule a free consultation with Al-Azhar-certified Sheikhs from Egypt.

Evidence used by those who prohibit it

Those who argue that Mawlid is haram they rely on the following evidence:

Hadith on innovation: The Prophet ﷺ said: “Every newly invented matter is an innovation, and every innovation is misguidance” (Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi). They take this hadith literally to include Mawlid.

They also rely on the hadith from Abdullah ibn ‘Amr رضي الله عنه who said: The Messenger of Allah ﷺ said: “There was no prophet whom Allah sent except that it was his duty to guide his people to the best of what he knew for them and to warn them against the worst of what he knew for them.” Reported by Muslim in his Sahih.

These scholars insist that when one asks “Is Mawlid Haram?”, the correct answer is yes, because they see it as contradicting the authentic Sunnah.

Evidence used by those who permit it

Al-Azhar and many other Sunni scholars have a different view. They say that the answer to “is Mawlid haram?” doesn’t need that complication. Celebrating Mawlid isn’t always haram; it depends on how people observe it. The evidence used by those who permit it includes:

Qur’anic encouragement of remembering Allah’s blessings: Allah says, “And remind them of the days of Allah” (Qur’an 14:5). The birth of the Prophet ﷺ is considered one of the greatest blessings for humanity.

Prophet Muhammad ﷺ used to fast Mondays and said, “That is the day I was born” (Sahih Muslim). This shows that remembering his birthday is a way of showing thanks.

Scholarly support across history: Great scholars like Imam Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti, Imam Ibn Hajar al-‘Asqalani, and others wrote in support of Mawlid, considering it a praiseworthy innovation if it includes acts of worship such as Qur’an recitation and charity.

Principle of bid‘ah hasanah (good innovation): The concept of bid‘ah hasanah means not all new practices are bad. Imam al-Shafi‘i said innovations can be good or bad. So, the scholars said If Mawlid helps people love the Prophet ﷺ and remember Allah, it is considered a good innovation.

Cultural traditions vs religious rulings

One major reason for confusion,  is mawlid Haram or allowed, is the overlap between culture and religion. In many countries and communities, like Egypt, Morocco, Sudan, Pakistan, and America, Mawlid is not only a religious celebration but also a cultural event. Streets are decorated, sweets are given out, and families come together to celebrate happily.

So scholars see that not every cultural practice is automatically religiously binding. For example:

If Mawlid is celebrated with reading the Qur’an, saying nasheed, giving charity, and learning about the Prophet’s life, it can help make faith stronger.

But if it involves things against Islamic teachings, like mixing freely, being too lavish, or musical events that go beyond Shariah limits, then those actions are haram. The celebration itself isn’t haram.

 

Balanced approach to the question

The balanced approach is neither complete prohibition nor unconditional approval. Instead, it is based on intention and method.

Allowed aspects: Remembering the Prophet ﷺ, reciting Qur’an, offering charity, and holding educational lectures are all praiseworthy acts. Doing them on Mawlid is a form of gratitude.

Not allowed aspects: Any sinful or excessive practices should be avoided. The prohibition applies to the wrong actions, not the celebration itself.

In this light, the answer to “Is Mawlid Haram?” becomes conditional: it is not haram in itself, but it becomes haram if practiced with impermissible elements. The most balanced answer is that one which the  Imam Jalal al-Din al-Suyuti tells us in his book “Husn al-Maqṣad fī ʿAmal al-Mawlid”:

“How should the Mawlid celebration be conducted, and what should be done or avoided? The celebration of the birth of the final Prophet ﷺ must be held in a manner that reflects the greatness of his message, faith, and mission.

Scholarly gatherings should be organized, through which Muslims can study their religion, learn how to solve their problems, and enable every believer to fulfill his role in building the edifice of Islam and preserving it until the Day of Judgment.

Those who are capable in religious matters should guide the Ummah of Muhammad ﷺ toward what benefits them and helps improve their conditions.

Muslims must revive the noble Seerah in order to follow it. They must devote themselves to studying Islamic history, for through it they and their Ummah will rise towards abundant goodness.

They must gain a deeper understanding (fiqh) of their religion. They must also reassess their conditions to reorganize their affairs, so they may proceed upon the path drawn for them by the noble Messenger ﷺ.

As for what is unbefitting in the celebration: indulging in heavy meals that only fill the stomachs, or similar acts unrelated to the spirit of Islam, and which do not aim at benefiting Muslims in their present or future—these have nothing to do with the legitimate celebration of the Mawlid.

Thus, the Mawlid celebration can either bring widespread benefit or cause harm and burden. If it brings benefit, it is welcomed; if it brings harm, it is condemned and rejected. Both reason and religion refuse that harm befall the Ummah under the name of celebrating the birth of its noble Prophet ﷺ”

Know more about Islamic law through Shariah (Islamic Jurisprudence) for beginners | Ar-Riwaq Al-Azhari.

Conclusion

So, is Mawlid haram? The answer isn’t clear-cut. Celebrating Mawlid is allowed if it helps build faith, inspires love for the Prophet ﷺ, and encourages worship. It becomes an issue when it includes things that are not allowed in Islam.

In the end, Mawlid can be a nice way to remember the Prophet’s kindness, personality, and teachings—as long as it follows Islamic rules. Like many things in Islamic law, the main points are balance, good intention, and using solid evidence.

Seize the opportunity for personalized Islamic learning with a free consultation from Egyptian Al-Azhar Sheikhs.

FAQs

Is Mawlid Haram according to all scholars?
No. Some scholars prohibit it, but many allow it as long as it does not involve any religious violations..

Is Mawlid Haram if celebrated with Qur’an recitation and charity only?
No. In fact, such forms are encouraged and considered praiseworthy.

What makes Mawlid Haram in some cases?
It becomes haram if mixed with impermissible acts such as extravagance, prohibited music, or practices resembling shirk.

Is Mawlid Haram for Muslims living in non-Muslim countries?
Not necessarily. Muslims may celebrate by holding lectures, feeding the poor, or remembering the Prophet ﷺ, as long as no prohibited acts are involved.